Home tools Buyer's Guides from tech enthusiast who loves technology and clever solutions for better living.
Best ice scrapers 2018 – [Buyer’s Guide]Last Updated January 1, 2019
Best ice scrapers of 2018
I have taken the initiative to educate you on the top three best ice scrapers that you can buy this year. I have a variety of material used in the construction of ice scrapers including metal, plastic, and glass. I am going to specify each good-to-buy feature as much as possible for your references. Many brands have introduced ice scrapers on the market. These brands have resulted in a variety for the user. These require that the consumers be well aware of what they are buying so as to make the best choice.
Test Results and Ratings
|Ease of use||
№1 – Snow MOOver 39″ Extendable and Ice Scraper with Foam Grip | Auto Snow Brush Scratch Free | Auto Ice Scraper | Car Truck SUV
Why did this ice scrapers win the first place?
I am very happy with the purchase. It is definitely worth its money. The product is top-notch! I don’t know anything about other models from this brand, but I am fully satisfied with this product. The rear part fits perfectly! It is mounted really tight and reliable. The product is very strong. Its material is stable and doesn’t crack.
Why did this ice scrapers come in second place?
I really liked it. It is amazing in every aspect. It did even exceed my expectations for a bit, considering the affordable price. Seems that the material is good. It has a very beautiful color but I don’t really like the texture. I like this product. For such a low price, I didn’t even hope it to be any better. It’s decently made. The design quality is top notch and the color is nice.
Why did this ice scrapers take third place?
I hope that the good reputation of the manufacturer will guarantee a long-term work. It doesn’t squeaks nor bents. Looks great in my apartment. I liked the design. We’ve been using it for 2 months and it still looks like brand new. This price is appropriate since the product is very well built.
ice scrapers Buyer’s Guide
Components of an Ice Scrapper
Most ice scrappers consist of a metallic handle, a piece of a wedge-shaped scrapper, and a snow brush (not all) at another end. The scraper is made of a sturdy plastic material with a set of ice cutting teeth in form of a dull blade. On the other hand, the snow brush has strong but smooth bristles on one edge and a rubber squeezer or foam on the other end.
Features of a good Ice Scrapper
Not all the ice scrappers that you see in the shops are good. Some are just imitation of the best brands made from fake materials. Therefore, you need to ensure that you look at some details and establish whether the product is genuine or not before purchasing.
The blade should be relatively sharp to cut through the ice easily. On the same note, the blade needs to be sturdy since sometimes you will need to bear it down when scraping the ice. Similarly, the ice cutting teeth should be shorter so that you can be able to scrap the windshield without necessarily forcing your knuckles in doing so.
The handle should have grips possibly made of something soft for example neoprene to maintain the grip. This is because hard materials like plastics are slippery and can be even more slippery if handled with gloves. Similarly, the handle needs to be strong and extendable to a length that would suit you and use without hassle. It should also be collapsible to a compact size that can fit in the car. The locking and unlocking buttons used when extending or collapsing the handles need to be sizeable enough to be operated with thick-gloved hands.
The Broom Head
The broom head needs to incorporate three tools that make it great in performance.The first tool is a bristle side that sweeps loose snow and the ice shavings. Another tool that must be at the broom head is the plow-like structure that enhances the pushing of snow from the vehicle. Furthermore, a broom head that can lock at multiple angels is an added advantage.
Hopkins Subzero 1662Ice Crusher Ice Scraper
This ice scraper from MakTools can remove the toughest ice with its extra sharp and yet non-abrasive blade without leaving any scratches. Also, this is ice scraper is very gentle on a surface and yet very tough on the job unlike other versions of ice scraper that scratch easily. This product can give you such an ease in your task without damaging or scratching your car’s window and windshields.
More so, the handle of this ice scraper product is covered with thick layer of foam that does make a comfortable grip for everyone. This handle is thicker and is sturdy as well as it is covered with foam, thus allowing a strong and secure grip. It’s a high-quality ice scraper and is made from solid ABS plastic giving you assurance that this product is really sturdy and durable, frost-proof and comes lightweight. If you are looking for a long lasting ice scraper that is surely sturdy and durable, choose this product it also comes with a unique and trendy design.
This ice scraper from Ice King is the most durable ice scraper on the market. This product is safe on windshields and has the leading edge which is then designed to work on any windshield without scratching. At the same time, this ice scraper product is considered to have the perfect grip and the contoured anti-freeze handle that allows for the perfect grip. Also, it comes with a carrying case which can keep your vehicle clean and organized with a free storage case and cloth. It is a product that is not made from a cheap plastic, but from a stainless steel which is durable and safe to use on any windshield. Ice King gives a lifetime replacement guarantee to all verified buyers of this ice scraper product.
This ice scraper product from Desired Tools is known to have the ability to remove the toughest of ice and snow with its extra sharp blade but without leaving scratches. More so, it has an extra thick and comfortable foam handle that is enabling it to have a strong grip for both men and women. Furthermore, it is longer than a regular one-handed ice scraper and portable enough to fit in your glove compartment for easy safekeeping. Also, it features a sharp yet non-abrasive and will never scratch car glass, a cheaper way to crush the thickest of icy snow, stylish design and color to fit your car, and the vibrant color that makes it easy to locate. This ice scraper product is very sturdy, frostproof, durable, lightweight and comes with a one-year warranty period from Desired Tools.
This Primary Automotive’s ice scraper was then forced out from the Spirit of the Rocky Mountains and was molded to endure the hardest scraping. This product features an extra thick plastic with reinforced buttresses that will surely smash through the ice like an ax, but do not worry about getting scratches because this ice scraper is very safe for your car windows. More so, it is built as a double-sided fighting tool, which you can use to attack the big ice with the Claw side and then scrape the sheets of the ice with the chisel side. Also, it has a foam grip for working on the most even grizzled of mountain men. The Primary Automotive gives a 10-year warranty period on this product to all verified purchase as well as confirms that this is the best ice scraper money can buy.
For most of the country, the winter months mean you can expect frost and probably snow, ice, and freezing rain. If you own a vehicle, that means you also need an ice scraper, likely one that incorporates a snow broom or brush. After more than 40 hours of research and real-world tests of 1models—the latest round an epic 28-windshield arm-breaker in a negative-3-degree cold-chamber at Ford’s winter-weather test facility in Detroit—we’re confident that the Hopkins 8003Quick-Lock Pivoting Snowbroom is the best scraper for most people.
After reviewing this entire guide, we no longer recommend the Swedish Ice Scraper for frost removal—the delivery costs make it too expensive. We still stand by our other picks, and we have added some long-term testing notes for our top pick, the Hopkins 8003Quick-Lock Pivoting Snowbroom, too.
Dart Seasonal Products CB9Telescopic Snow Brush
How we picked
Other than the Swedish Ice Scraper, our test models all share a similar basic shape: They consist of a metal handle with a one-piece wedge-shaped scraper at one end and a snow brush on the other. The scraper (which is made of plastic) has a set of ice-cutting teeth on its flat back and a thick, relatively dull blade at its fore end; the brush usually has bristles on one edge and a rubber or foam squeegee on the other.
The Swedish Ice Scraper (top center) is utterly unique; conventional ice scrapers all share a similar design. But compare the small, narrow-set teeth on the runner-up Dart Seasonal (bottom center) against the prominent, wide-set teeth on our pick, the Hopkins 8003(bottom left)—details like that make a big difference in performance.
But the details of the design make all the difference between scrapers, and every part of the scraper is important.
The blade needs to be relatively sharp and also extremely sturdy—when scraping ice, you often need to bear down hard.
The ice-cutting teeth need to be tall and prominent so that they contact the windshield without forcing your knuckles to do so, and ideally they extend along the entire width of the blade, so that you cut the maximally wide swath when using them.
The handle should have grips made of something soft, like neoprene; hard-plastic grips are slippery, especially in gloved hands (and even more so in wool mitts). And, when the handles are extended, they should lock into place automatically and not require you to line up the locking pins with their lockholes. Naturally, the handles should also be strong. They should extend to a length that allows you to push snow and scrape ice off even a big vehicle; about 60 inches (feet) is standard for trucks and SUVs. Yet ideally, when collapsed, the scrapers should be short enough that the tool can be stored in any vehicle, even a subcompact.
Inside Ford’s climate-controlled test room, it was -°F. And they had taken it easy on us: That room can go down to -40 °F and up to 12°F.
How do you test ice scrapers in an unusually warm autumn? You ask Ford if you can borrow the industrial facility those folks use to trial their vehicles in extreme conditions. To our luck, Ford gave an enthusiastic yes to our request that we come to Detroit for a test.
It was an unusually warm 7°F outside on the day we arrived—but inside Ford’s climate-controlled test room, it was -°F. And they had taken it easy on us: That particular room can go down to -40 °F and up to 122 °F.
We brought seven scrapers to test; Ford brought an Explorer SUV and a Focus sedan. Using paint sprayers filled with tap water, engineers Dale Snapp and Justin Dorazio began by laying down a thick coating of ice on the vehicles’ windshields. They made multiple passes, building up the ice in layers. The water began to freeze immediately; they may as well have been spraying instant-dry paint (see Snapp in the GIF above). After each spray-down, we waited five minutes to allow the ice to fully harden. Then, we scraped each windshield in turn, with one of us keeping the time. We cycled through the scrapers, one by one and vehicle by vehicle; in between scrapers, we took notes and warmed up in the adjacent control room. We then did a second test of each scraper, after the room was raised to a balmy 1°F. After six hours and 2scraped windshields (two vehicles times seven scrapers times two test temperatures), we had sore shoulders, numb toes, and our results—a notebook’s worth of observations.
Chief among them: A rose is a rose is a rose, but not all ice is identical—and not all scrapers handle every type of ice well. Going into the test, we were hoping we’d get to pit our scrapers against one particularly challenging form: the paper-thin, paper-white kind that forms during a hard frost or light freezing rain. Clearing it from windshields is the toughest job scrapers are asked to do—an observation that comes from our own real-world experience, and from Mike Williams, chief marketing officer of Hopkins Manufacturing, producer of the Sub Zero line of ice scrapers (which have scored well in our tests). As it happened, Ford’s paint sprayers made exactly that sort of ice on the Explorer’s windshield, which faced directly into the cold-room’s chillers.
The reason thin ice is hard to scrape is due to a basic compromise most ice-scraper manufacturers make: blade toughness over blade sharpness. Ice-scraper blades are generally made of plastic, which is very resilient but not very hard. That means the blades can’t be made very sharp; in fact, the edges of all but one of the scrapers we tested were visibly rounded like the edge of a piece of posterboard. They were “sharp” in the sense of being relatively thin, but not sharp in the sense of “liable to cut.” And in order to cut through paper-thin ice, you need a blade edge that’s even thinner.
Only the Swedish Ice Scraper (top center) shaved thin, rock-hard ice right down to the glass—and it would have cleaned off the whole windshield if we’d held it the right way (pointed end toward the ground) when scraping the passenger side. No other scraper came close.
Flaws but not dealbreakers
Like every scraper we tested (except for the Swedish Ice Scraper), the Hopkins 8003performed poorly on thin, hard ice—the kind that formed on the Explorer’s windshield, facing directly into the cold-room’s chillers (see the photo in How we tested). But because that’s a shortcoming shared by every other standard-style scraper we tested, we don’t take it as a fatal flaw: As we outlined above, most scraper manufacturers favor toughness (for thick ice) over sharpness (for thin, hard ice), and in practice that means all their blades are very similar in form. Moreover, all our standard scrapers performed well on the thin but much softer ice that formed on the Focus’s windshield, sheltered at the back of the cold-room. And that’s the sort of ice people will face most of the time in the real world.
The Hopkins 1403is an excellent tool—it’s our pick from last year. It’s fast, it’s light, and it’s perfectly balanced and therefore especially easy to control. But it has only a broom—not a combination broom and plow—which means that after a blizzard, it won’t be much use until you’ve used another tool to sweep the snow off your car.
Hopkins 14180 Ultimate Crossover Snowbroom is a new model with a specially designed flexible blade that’s supposed to conform better to the curves of windshields, improving scraping performance. In our test, though, we didn’t notice much difference; we’ll test it again in the future, but for now we’re happier sticking with the tried-and-true 80037.
The Blizzerator Professional Auto Ice Scraper was a previous pick for large vehicles. On retesting, its weaknesses stood out more than its strengths. When telescoping, the handles can rotate, meaning you have to line up the locking pins by eye; our pick and runner-up lock into place automatically. And the Blizzerator’s broom/plow head is terribly designed. Only the broom rotates; the plow remains fixed, parallel to the handle. So, when plowing snow, you have to sweep sideways instead of pushing—stressing both the handle and your spine—while, when sweeping, the “prow” of the plow extends inches in front of the broom, making it impossible to get into the tight spots the broom is supposed to clean out.
With an efficient design and precise, laser-cut, and diamond-polished acrylic edges, the Swedish Ice Scraper provided the best ice-scraping performance of all. But it’s pricier than other dedicated scrapers because it needs to be ordered from Sweden.
The Iceplane is a variation on the credit card school of ice scraping. Its two medium-thick plastic blades are attached along the long axis of a rod to form a V-shape, like an open book. You shove the Iceplane into the ice, and if you hit it right, the blade will slip under and push a chunk off. Using the Iceplane is more comfortable than using a credit card, thanks to the nice round handle, but it’s almost as slow; it took us nearly five minutes to clear a side window in our original testing. The Iceplane lacks the ice-scoring spikes that make the best scrapers work so quickly. It can be very meditative to stand out in the cold going scritch, scritch, scritch on your windshield, but if you want to get to work on time in the morning, choose a different scraper.
The Snow Joe Edge Ice Scraper with Brass Blade is just like the little brass scrapers they give away for free at banks with branches in the frozen tundra (like the Caribou Credit Union), only it’s bigger—it’s 12½ inches long and inches wide! And with it, clearing ice off your car window will still take forever, because the Snow Joe Edge lacks ice-scraper spikes to break the ice into smaller chunks.
The Innovation Factory IceDozer Classic 2.0 Ice Scraper also did a splendid job of dispensing with ice—with it, we cleared the window in just minutes, 4seconds. It all would have gone faster, though, if we could have used this tool’s large ice-scoring teeth. The IceDozer Classic has two sets of ice-scoring teeth: one batch that is less than half as tall as the set on the Hopkins, and one set that sits in line with a kind of plastic wall that makes it impossible to use their full height for attacking window ice. The IceDozer Classic comes with helpful instructions about how to hold and move it to deal with thin, medium, and thick ice, and its fluted plastic handles were well-located and easy to grip for us, all of which makes up somewhat for the fact that the black scraping blade isn’t particularly sharp and the gray Frost Peeler blade doesn’t slide under the ice and pry it up like typical scrapers: It pushes ice away. Because you push the ice instead of prying it, the IceDozer Classic is virtually impossible to use one-handed—you just can’t get enough force behind it. Still, we didn’t find it as effective as other scrapers that had larger, more accessible teeth. Let’s hope that Innovation Factory redesigns the IceDozer Classic’s ice teeth to work as well as its handles.
The OXO Good Grips Extendable Twister Snowbrush has a solid handle, a rotatable snow brush, and a sharp blade, but no teeth for scoring thick ice. We managed to cut away a bit by using the scraper corner, but it was slow; clearing the window took almost minutes.
The Ice Master consists of a set of three brass ice-scraping blades that rotate and fold around a handle but never seem to end up in a position that allows you to scrape ice effectively. It took us frozen minutes and 40 frigid seconds to get the window clear with that thing. Learn from our mistakes and buy a different scraper.
The brush is highly versatile. One can put it to use effortlessly. Unlike other brushes, it doesn’t demand much maintenance. The quality justifies the price. The tool can be easily used by the people having short heights. The foam grip is moisture-resistant and comfy.
Get ready to deal with the discomfort caused to you by snow with this extendable snow broom. The length can be adjusted between 30 and 5inches in order to serve the purpose. The broom features exceedingly flexible bristles that will work gently. The wide base can move a lot more snow as compared to the competitors.
SnowBrum Original snow removal tool
The scraper provides you with approx 4inches reach to sweep off the snow from your vehicle effectively. Unlike typical snow brush, this scraper is super effective to reach across the width of the windshield of sport utility vehicles and minivans.
Hopkins 2610XM Subzero 52” super extender sunbroom
This heavy duty broom is one of the revolutionary snow tools. This super good tool is small enough to fit into the trunk of your car and long enough so you don’t need to climb up to reach the top of your car.
Are you looking for an efficient and easy to use snow and ice scraper? Then worry no more. This product by the birdrock Company is effective and can easily get rid of ice from the top of your car, the windshield, and the hood. It extends to 55” and removes even the unreachable snow and ice that may damage your car, truck or Suv. Its handle can be extended for easier ice and snow elimination operations from your vehicle.
It has jaws made of extra thick plastic and a flat ice scrapper. The jaws are useful for breaking and eliminate the bigger ice particles with much ease. This product is equipped with a removable ice scraper which can be alternatively used for cleaning the windows. Its functioning has also been tested on snowy and rocky mountains and proved to perform exceedingly.
Do you own a car? Are you worried about the oncoming ice and snow that may end up destroying your vehicle’s windshield and windows? Then, count yourself lucky for encountering this snow and ice scraper. It has the power to eliminate even the slightest amount of ice or snow from any surface effortlessly.
The blades used in the making of this product are constructed from a non-abrasive brass material which makes them robust and durable. Its construction features four blade positions which allow this tool to work in any of your preferred direction. This ice and snow scraper will never slip from your hands, thanks to the included well-textured rubber handle.
Suncast SSD7500 8-Inch Snow & Ice Scraper
It also features a tempered galvanized steel blade which ensures even the toughest snow pieces are eliminated with ease. Its handle is smooth and comes from a steel core which makes it durable. The blade measures inches in length while the whole scraper measures approximately 5inches in length. It’s a product from the USA.
While we don’t normally advocate leaving a car idling, starting the car and turning these on will clear window fog before you start out. They’re not intended to melt snow or ice, though: you’ll still need to get out and clean off the glass.
Scrape away any ice
Choose a shorter-handled ice scraper, or the one on your snow brush, depending on what’s easiest for your height and strength. You need to scrape the glass, not the ice, so work the blade under the edge of the ice sheet. Be careful around the wipers, to avoid gouging the rubber with the scraper blade.
Watch those wipers!
Don’t turn on the wipers until you’re sure the blades aren’t frozen to the glass. If they are, you could damage the blades or the wiper motor. Work them completely free with your fingers. This can be easier if you’ve had the defroster on for a few minutes. Some vehicles have wiper de-icers, which are heated wires (similar to the rear-window defogger) in the lower part of the windshield.
Cover up your windshield
Placing a windshield cover over the glass before you park the car at night can speed up the clean-off process. You just remove the cover and the white stuff comes with it. Shake the cover thoroughly, since you don’t want it dripping in your trunk or cargo area.
Change your wiper blades
Many drivers hang on to their blades long after they’re past their prime. Replace them any time they tear or leave streaks: it’s cheap insurance for good visibility. Winter blades are formulated to stay supple when the temperature drops, and their shape helps prevent ice from building up on them.
Know your vehicle
If you bought your car while the weather was still nice, you may not be familiar with all of its controls. Be sure you can quickly find the defroster and rear defogger buttons or settings. If you have heated mirrors, check the owner’s manual to see how they work. Some need to be turned on with a button, or only activate when the rear defogger is on.
Here are a few questions to ask yourself before you start shopping.
Do You Experience a Lot of Snow? Ice? Both? If you live in a climate which has winter frost, but not so much snow (for example, the Southern part of the United States), you can get away with a smaller tool, so long as it has a blade with serious ice removing capabilities. If you live in a region with a lot of snow during the winter (such as Northeastern and Midwestern states), you will benefit from buying an ice scraper with an attached snow broom. That way you can clean both snow and ice off your vehicle with just one tool.
Do You Have a Vehicle with a Hard-To-Reach Roof? If you have a big SUV, or if you are on the short side and find it hard to reach the middle of your windshield, look for a tool with an extendible handle. This will help you remove snow and ice from every part of your car.
Design and Construction
Ice scrapers are fairly simple tools, but every element is important. Here are some key features to look for.
Blade – The key to a great ice scraper is a sharp blade that will chip away ice without damaging your windshield.
In addition to being sharp, the blade needs to be durable. Thin ice can be especially tricky, and you often need to use plenty of elbow grease in the process. You need a blade that will withstand this sort of pressure.
Snow Broom – If you live in a snowy climate, you will need to sweep snow off your windows as well as the roof of your car. Failing to do the latter can endanger those on the road around you, as large amounts of snow may fly off the roof of your car while you drive.
The best models for snowy climates comprise a traditional ice scraper at one end, with a long metal handle that contains a bristled snow brush on the opposite end.
Some models even allow you to angle the snow broom at various degrees, depending on the part of your vehicle that needs clearing.
Handle – Most people will be wearing gloves when removing snow and ice from their vehicle, so the best handles will be designed with this in mind.
Look for soft padded grips that will reduce the slipperiness of the plastic or metal base.
Hopkins 8003Subzero Snowbroom
This model has a snow broom that won’t scratch the paint on your vehicle. The broom head can be adjusted to seven different angles so you can easily clear snow off every surface of your car.
It also has a squeegee that clears panels and curved surfaces, as well as an attached plow that pushes large amounts of snow out of the way quickly.
The handle extends so you can reach the roof of your vehicle with ease, but it collapses to only feet, so it can be stored in the trunk of any car. The buttons are easy to use while wearing gloves and the handles are padded with neoprene grips to reduce slippage.
This all-in-one ice scraper is a terrific product that makes winter a lot easier to get through.
Bully Tools 92200 Ice Scraper
If you are looking for an ice scraper to clear ice off your sidewalks, rather than your vehicle, our recommendation is the Bully Tools 92200 Sidewalk Scraper. This is a heavy-duty product that can slice through even the thickest layers of ice that settle onto surfaces during harsh winters.
The tool is crafted entirely from steel. It features an 11” blade. All you need to do is lift it up over a patch of snow and ice, and then let it drop. The force of gravity will be enough to crack up to half an inch of ice at a time.
This American-made tool is virtually indestructible and is backed by a lifetime warranty.
If you’re looking for a durable tool to make clearing your driveway and sidewalks less of a nightmare, this product from Bully Tools is a perfect choice for you.
Hopkins 1403Subzero Snowbroom
The most interesting feature of this model is its curved extendible handle. The ergonomic design gives you extra leverage, making it super easy to remove snow and ice from your windshield and roof.
The handle extends to 50” for ultimate reach and reduces down to 36” for convenient storage. There are several notches in between so you can find an ideal length to work with.
This tool also has a snow brush head that pivots, so you can sweep sheets of snow off your vehicle in no time. If you are dealing with extra wet and heavy snow, simply push a button to convert the brush into a sturdy broom.
How We Work
Test Facts uses a fact-based approach to product reviews. All reviews are created based on in-depth research, product tests and analysis.
We have developed and improved our approach for years to give our visitors the most accurate product top lists online.
First of all thanks for reading my article to the end! I hope you find my reviews listed here useful and that it allows you to make a proper comparison of what is best to fit your needs and budget. Don’t be afraid to try more than one product if your first pick doesn’t do the trick.
Most important, have fun and choose your ice scrapers wisely! Good luck!
So, TOP3 of ice scrapers
- №1 — Snow MOOver 39″ Extendable and Ice Scraper with Foam Grip | Auto Snow Brush Scratch Free | Auto Ice Scraper | Car Truck SUV
- №2 — Pennzoil Automotive 9 Inch Bear Claw Ice Scraper in Black
- №3 — Hopkins 532 Mallory 26″ Snow Brush with Foam Grip